5 Classic Cigars Every Newbie Should Try at Least Once

May 9th 2025

5 Classic Cigars Every Newbie Should Try at Least Once

When stepping into the world of cigars, every newbie—novice or seasoned—deserves to experience the timeless craftsmanship behind a classic smoke. At Bonita Smoke Shop, our team has helped countless customers find their perfect match. Whether you’re exploring your first cigar or looking to round out your humidor, here are five timeless selections that belong on every smoker’s must-try list.


1. Don Diego Connecticut

Profile: Mild | Silky | Dominican

This cigar delivers a silky texture and light flavor that’s approachable for beginners and satisfying for experienced smokers. Known for its consistent construction and mellow body, it’s ideal for those who want a balanced experience without overwhelming strength.

Pairing Tip: Enjoy it with a Cuban coffee to enhance its creaminess.


2. Espinosa Crema

Profile: Mild | Creamy | Nicaraguan

Smooth and mellow with a creamy flavor profile, this cigar is a favorite for those stepping into boutique blends. It offers a refined draw and elegant texture without being too bold.

Best Size: A Robusto (5”x50) keeps things flavorful and manageable in length.


3. Perla Del Mar (PDM) Shade

Profile: Mild | Smooth | Budget-Friendly

A solid everyday cigar with a smooth draw and approachable flavor. Its price point makes it ideal for new smokers or for gifting without breaking the bank.

Pro Tip: A great “starter” cigar to share with friends or enjoy on your own.


4. Arturo Fuente Chateau Series

Profile: Mild-Medium | Smooth | Dominican

A soft introduction to premium heritage cigars. This stick offers great flavor without intensity, showcasing the craftsmanship of Dominican tobacco under an Ecuadorian wrapper.

Clarification: “Robusto” refers to the size, not strength—many new smokers mix that up.


5. Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real

Profile: Mild-Medium | Recognizable | Creamy

Known globally, this cigar brings creamy flavors and a subtle sweetness that appeals to both new and seasoned smokers. It’s a cigar that carries name recognition while delivering a smooth experience.

Pairing Idea: Pairs well with lighter beverages like beer or sweet bourbon.


Beginner Tips from the Bonita Smoke Shop Team

  • Start Mild, Not Bold: Go for mild cigars first to develop your palate before trying full-bodied options.
  • Budget Sweet Spot: Great cigars exist in the $10–$15 range—plenty of quality without overspending.
  • Storage Savvy: Always ask if cigars are kept in a walk-in humidor. Visual checks and feel tests aren’t always reliable for freshness.
  • Cut with Precision: A straight cut works best for beginners—don’t cut past the cap to avoid unraveling.
  • Light with Patience: Toast the edges first, then light the center with puffs. Over-scorching can ruin the first few draws.

Final Words: Relax, Don’t Flex

There’s no one way to enjoy a cigar. It’s not a competition—it’s a personal experience. Take your time, explore different blends, and most importantly, enjoy the journey. The team at Bonita Smoke Shop is here to help every step of the way.